JOAN OF ARC One historian has written, “No one can hope to explain…
Question Answered step-by-step JOAN OF ARC One historian has written, “No one can hope to explain… JOAN OF ARC One historian has written, “No one can hope to explain Joan of Arc, & possibly we should not try.” The first selection , written by her accusers, is from her trial. The second is the sentence delivered against her in 1431. She replied that she confessed she brought news from God to her king; & that Our Lord would restore his kingdoms to him, have him crowned at Rheims, & drive out his enemies. And that she was God’s messenger in telling him that he must put her boldly to work, & that she would raise the siege of Orleans. She said also that she had said: All the kingdom. & that if my lord pf Burgundy & the other subjects of the realm did not come to obedience, the king would make them do so by force. Questioned . . . if she believed that she is not bound to submit her words & deeds to . . . any other than God, she answered: I will maintain what I have always said at my trial. And if I were to be condemned & saw the fire lit & the wood prepared & the executioner who was to burn me ready to cast me into the fire, still in the fire would I not say anything than I have said. And I will maintain what I have said until death. Therefore, we . . . have declared by impartial judgement that you, Joan, have commonly called the Maiden, have fallen into various errors & diverse crimes of schism, idolatry, invocation of demons, & several other misdeeds. However, since the church does not close its lap to those who return to her . . . & since, on a certain day, you renounced your errors & crimes, publicly made an oath & vows & promises never to return to these errors or any heresy, . . . even as is more fully explained in the document signed by your own hand; considering that in the course of time, . . . you had relapsed, O sorrow into those errors & crimes, just as a doge returns to its vomit, . . . we have recognized by very well known sentences that, with feint heart rather than with a true & faithful spirit you have denied only with your mouth your previous inventions & errors. For these reasons . . . we judge that you are a relapsed heretic. . . . and we reject you, cut you away, abandon you, . . . QUESTIONSWhose kingdom did Joan believe God would help restore?Who is the enemy to which Joan refers to in the 1st paragraph?What service did Joan provide for God?A. To whom does Joan believe she must “submit her words & deeds”?B. Why might church officials dislike this answer? 5. What evidence is there that Joan renounced her errors & crimes at one time? 6. From you readings in the chapter, what is the penalty for a relapsed heretic? History World History HIS 111 Share QuestionEmailCopy link Comments (0)


