The Mekong River

 

The Mekong River is shared by people of China, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam. In “Mekong River” by Jeffrey W. Jacobs, Lewis Owen and Gilbert F. White, we are informed that “Rising in southeastern Qinghai province, China, it flows through the eastern part of the Tibet Autonomous Region and Yunnan province, after which it forms part of the international border between Myanmar (Burma) and Laos, as well as between Laos and Thailand. The river then flows through Laos, Cambodia, and Vietnam before draining into the South China Sea south of Ho Chi Minh City”. It shows that China is the upper stream country, while Vietnam is the last country that is receiving the river. In “River Politics: China’s Policies In The Mekong And The Brahmaputra In Comparative Perspective” by Selina Ho, she claims that now that China has become stronger, it is ready for the cooperative development of the Mekong River, but the cooperation is not easy due to different interests of different countries (Ho 2). For example, dam building is a highly controversial topic among these countries. China has built two dams in 1996 and 2002 in order to get more electricity, control the water flow and stop the landslides and mudslide. Laos also wants to build a dam in their country with the same purpose. The Chinese have argued that the dams will have little impact on the lower basin because the Lancang Jiang only contributes 16% of the Mekong’s total discharge, while other countries claim that China’s dams in the mainstream have a significant impact on sediment balance and on the aquatic life of the river (Ho 9). Patently, China has an excuse to build dams for its own development, but there are more negative impacts on the downstream countries, such as, water shortage and livelihood problems associated with it. Since Vietnam is the last country that is receiving the river, it suffers the most because of dam building. Reduction water and sediment of the Mekong River, which is due to dam building, leads to significant salinization phenomenon of the Mekong Delta, Vietnam. Their livelihood is now threatened because it is a disaster for their fisheries and rice growing. However, China is the most powerful country in the East Asia, it has the biggest voice on what happens. Thus, other countries like Vietnam can’t do anything that stops it happening. In the discussion of the Mekong River, one controversial issue has been how small countries like Vietnam solve water sharing problems when having to negotiate powerful countries like China.

All in all, there are lots of problems on sharing international water among China, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam due to dam building. Thus, in the following paragraphs, the positive and negative impact of dam building will be discussed.

One of the advantages of dam construction is to adjust the water levels during dry and flood seasons. Dam plays an important role in storing water for the dry season and controlling flooding in the rainy season. It is the most effective way to resolve contradictions of uneven distribution of water resources among these countries. It is also the contemporary fundamental way to solve water shortage of international water. According to the historical records, the upstream of Mekong River had existed a serious problem of flood and drought. Early on in the narrative, China began to build upstream dams since the 90’s of the last century. According to the most recent study on the topic “models dam impacts of the Yunnan cascade in three scenarios (no dams, the first three dams completed, six dams completed). Their modeling results and predictions are well in line with several previous studies and suggest a 20-22 % decrease in June-November flows and a 90 % increase in December–May flows”(Kuenzer 574). From the data, we can deduce that dam construction in the upper-stream of Mekong River has a positive effect on regulating the water flow during two seasons to some extent. In “Sediment-related impacts due to upstream reservoir trapping, the Lower Mekong River” by Matti Kummu and Olli Varis, the authors point out that on positive impact is that increased dry season flow decreases the risk of water shortages and increases the options for dry season irrigation”(Kummu and Varis 287). They also mention that dam construction on the upstream has some benefits for rice farming and navigational activities in the Lower Mekong Basin because of its function of increasing dry season flow. They explain that certain benefits of dam building should not be denied.

Another beneficial effect of dam construction in the Mekong River is to offer clean electricity through developing the exploitation of water. Hydropower is currently one of the most important means of reducing greenhouse gases. Scientific studies have confirmed that the current climate in many parts of the world, for example, storms, droughts and other extreme weather are occurring frequently, which is most likely due to some humans activities related with excessive greenhouse gas emissions. Nowadays, the exploitation of hydropower is an alternative to fossil energy, and it is fundamentally the most important measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. “Hydropower is a lucrative energy market, and the governments and media of countries with a potential for dams promote hydropower as a source of green and clean energy, superior to dangerous or polluting nuclear or coal-based energy”(Kuenzer 568). What the author tries to tell us is that hydropower from dams is green and clean energy that is better that nuclear power and coal-based energy. In fact, the majority of countries are giving priority to the development of hydropower because it is one of the most energy-saving and effective ways of emission reductions. For example, Xayaburi dam is located in the northern part of Laos, and the project will be completed in the end of 2019. Xayaburi dam is proposed to build 12 dams in the first, designed generation capacity of 1.26 million-kilowatt. It is the first large hydropower projects plan for the dam construction of the Mekong River. As one of the world’s poorest countries, Laos regards the hydropower industry as “the battery of Southeast Asia” (BBC News 2012) and a key to the future development of the industry. The construction of the dam will not only develop the economy of the country but also offer Lao lots of clean resource. Therefore, active exploitation of hydropower is the most important way to mitigate the Mekong River water resources crisis. Specifically, in order to deal with this water resources crisis and pollution of the river, dam building is irreplaceable.

However, there are some disadvantages of dam building as well. It is harmful to both the natural and cultural environment of the downstream countries.

The construction of dam breaks down the self-clarification system of the river. In order to develop the economy, people from the upper Mekong River County build factories around the dam and throw the polluted water into the river without any pollution controls. Wenbo, a specialist from the U.S. Pacific Environment’s Chinese Program, claims that after dams have built, water flow slows down in the Mekong River, and its self-purification capacity will be greatly reduced (“Experts Speaking on Mekong pollution”). What he tries to say is that the Mekong River has its numerous problems, such as, unsteady water flow and pollution, however, damn building worsens the water pollution. Even worse, plants and farms are replaced by dams and industrial factories, which leads to worsening of food shortages. Many local residents have to leave their home because of government’s compulsory remove (“Experts Speaking on Mekong pollution”). Consequently, the construction of the dam is a threat to people’s lives and livelihood.

Building a dam on the Mekong River can slow down or even stop the economic growth, especially fisheries. Most of economic growth of the downstream countries are depending on the agriculture, for example, Vietnam. Firstly, dam building in China would lead to the reduction of sedimentation downstream. It is the most important food source for fish, so it will reduce the quantities and qualities of the fish in the downstream. Secondly, The Lancang dams have also altered water temperatures. In the review “Understanding the Impacts of China’s Upper Mekong Dams”, we have learnt that “the decrease in water temperature and the increase in water temperature fluctuation will change the behaviors of fish species, impacting their reproduction and migration activities”. The review explains why the water temperature change will cause the reproduction rate of fish in the river getting lower. Thirdly, the dams also block the migratory of fish, which are critical for reproduction, so it would also reduce the quantities of the fish in the downstream. The three facts tell us the building of dam strongly affect fisheries in the downstream countries in a bad way, for example, Vietnam. A report, written by Institute of Natural Resources and Environmental Management in Chiang Rai Luang University in Thailand and Portland State University of Oregon in the United States, is about the economic, environmental and social impacts of hydropower development in the Mekong River downstream. The report shows that fish catches in Vietnam is 340,000 tons per year. However, if other countries build 6 main stream dams and 30 tributary dams, Vietnam would lose 60,000 tom per year of the catch of fish. In other words, Vietnam just gets 280,000 ton per year. Furthermore, if other countries build 11 dams in the main stream and 30 dams in the tributary, Vietnam would lose 140,000 tons per year of the catch of fish. In other words, Vietnam only gets 200,000 tons per year, which is only 59 percent of what Vietnam can get right now. The loss of fish catches would lower down the economic growth and the income of the Vietnamese. Additionally, Vietnam is a developing country, and its GPA growth is mainly from the agriculture. The livelihood of 20 million of the population depend on fish catches in the Mekong River, and 27 percent of the GPA growth is from fish catches. In conclusion, building more dams would make the economy of fishery goes down which is against the benefit of the downstream countries’ livelihood.

Moreover, building of dam not only slower the development of fisheries economy, but also affect economy of planting industry in a negative way. Rice-growing is the big part of the planting industry in the agriculture. The agriculture in the downstream depends on the water resource from the Mekong River. First of all, the landslides and mudslides from the upstream is a perfect fertilizer nutrient for the growth of plants. The farmers, for example, from Thailand, would get the landslides and mudslides from the Mekong River to keep the soil fertile, which is a great condition for the rice growth. Also, the countries in the upstream would use the dams to control the water resource. If the dams reduce the water resource to the downstream, farmers would not have enough water to irrigate the rice, fruits, and vegetables. According to Vietnamese People Daily, reported on March 4th 2016, the Longjiang plain suffered the most serious drought and salt damage in the year. The crop will be reduced by 224 thousand tons per year, and the agriculture and fisheries total loss of about 5 trillion and 200 billion rupiah, which about 230 million dollar, accounting for the total area 2.3 percent of GDP. It shows that the Longjiang plain surrounding the Mekong River suffer from drought because the climate changes and the water resource in the river is reduced, and the countries had a big economic loss from that drought. On the other hand, if the dams discharge too much water to the downstream, the plants would die. According to the report, the production of rice would reduce 175 million dollar if they build 6 dams in the main stream and 30 dams in the distributary. Besides, once they build 11 dams in the main stream and 30 in the distributary, the production of rice would reduce 278 million dollar per year. It would be a disaster for the downstream countries’ economy. As a result, people living in that area would have a hard time. Because the fishery and rice-growing are reduced, people’s income are reduce in a huge amount, so the survival problem becomes a big problem. People would not have enough food to eat, and their clean drinking water is not enough. Moreover, many people would lose their jobs, and the unemployment rate will be raise so fast. So, building more dams would make the rice–growing economy decrease, and damage people’s livelihood.

After reviewing all data that we collect from the Internet, we realize that the problem is not just about dam, but it starts with dam. In an article from Bloomberg Market, Yoolim Lee state that China needs electricity to fuel its fast growth, has already built four dams on the Mekong, completing the first one in 1993 without consulting its downstream neighbors (Lee). This is what people in the downstream countries think about China’s hydropower dams. Chinese government just does whatever they want for themselves without considering others’ interest. What should small countries do to get what they want? How can they make giant China listen to their opinions? It is a big challenge for small countries because they are not strong enough to speak for themselves and resist a powerful country. Therefore, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam should combined together against China’s dam construction plan or other action without consulting with them. Only in this way can small countries can protect their interest and enhance international influence.

Works Cited

BBC News (2012) Laos hydropower a ‘‘battery” for power-hungry region. BBC News.                        BBC. 2010-10-12. http://www.bbc.co.uk/ news/11962210. Web. 27 Sep. 2016.

“Experts Speaking on Mekong pollution.” Radio Free Asia. N.p., n.d. Web. 03 Oct. 2016.

Ho, Selina. “River Politics: China’s Policies In The Mekong And The Brahmaputra In Comparative Perspective.” Journal Of Contemporary China 23.85 (2014): 1-20. Academic Search Premier. Web. 3 Oct. 2016.

Intralawan, Apisom, David Wood, and Richard Frankel. Economic, Environmental and Social Impacts of Hydropower Development in the Mekong River Downstream. Rep. no. 15. Institute of Natural Resources and Environmental Management, Thailand Chiang Rai Luang University. N.p.: n.p., 2015. Print.

Jacobs, Jeffrey W., Owen, Lewis, and White, Gilbert F. “Mekong River.” Encyclopedia Britannica Online. Encyclopedia Britannica, n.d. Web. 03 Oct. 2016.

Kuenzer, Claudia. “Understanding the impact of hydropower developments in the context of upstream–downstream relations in the Mekong river basin.” Sustainability science 8.4 (2013): 565-584. Web. 27 Sep. 2016.

Kummu, Matti, and Varis, Olli. “Sediment-related impacts due to upstream reservoir trapping, the Lower Mekong River.” Geomorphology 85.3 (2007): 275-293. Web. 27 Sep. 2016.

Lee, Yoolim. “China Hydropower Dams in Mekong River Give Shocks to 60 Million.” Bloomberg.com. Bloomberg, n.d. Web. 03 Oct. 2016.

“Understanding the Impacts of China’s Upper Mekong Dams.” International Rivers. N.p., n.d. Web. 03 Oct. 2016.